AstronomyFeaturedillusionsPhotographyScience & NatureSkepticism

Bad Moon Rising

IMG_6408-2-110

It was the night of February 27th, 2013. Rob and I were driving down a stretch of dark highway when it happened. As we crested a hill something strange appeared at the horizon: an orange, glowing, ovoid object slowly rising from the earth like a distant bubble of blooming magma – fiery and ominous. After the initial surprise of the unsettling sight I quickly realized that it was just the moon. But my goodness, it was so surreal-looking; so much larger than usual, with a rich orange hue, and strangely squashed.

By the time we got home, the moon was higher in the sky. While I couldn’t capture the full effect of what we had experienced while we were driving, I was able to catch its distorted shape and color, just not as pronounced as it was when the moon was low on the horizon.

It’s not hard to imagine how superstitions surrounding such events come about. We perceive something strange and have to come up with a reason or purpose for its occurrence. It’s the way our minds work and sometimes we just can’t help it.

A search through Google about “red/orange moon superstitions”  gives you numerous examples of past superstitions such as:

  • when the moon is orange it means that the moon is angry
  • it signifies something horrible is about to happen to you
  • a death in the family is about to occur
  • war is imminent
  • it is a sign of good luck

How popular these beliefs were in the past or how many of these beliefs are still held by some people is hard to tell. I’m hoping that we can all agree such superstition is ridiculous, yet there are countless modern, educated people who experience strange or unexplained phenomena and choose to classify it as proof of the supernatural rather than what it truly is: something which they simply don’t understand or may have misperceived.

So, what caused this wondrous lunar event?

First off, the cause of the orange color: when viewing the moon on the horizon, the Earth’s atmosphere causes the light of the moon to be dispersed differently. Since the atmosphere is thicker when looking at the sky on the horizon, the blue light is dispersed in the atmosphere and the red/orange light is what ends up coming through. This frequently happens to the sun at sunrise and sunset, but it’s harder to catch and to notice the effect on the moon.

IMG_6412-111

This is how the moon looked by the time we arrived home. The color change is obvious, but do you notice its slightly pinched appearance?

The moon’s distorted shape was also because of the atmosphere. It acts as a lens, bending and distorting the light – an effect called “atmospheric refraction”. Atmospheric refraction also causes the wavy distortion when looking through the air above hot surfaces and it is what makes the stars twinkle.

As for the moon looking bigger, this actually isn’t caused by atmospheric refraction.  As a matter of fact, the moon is slightly smaller when it is at the horizon because it’s farther away (as illustrated in the picture below). So what’s the deal? Two words: moon illusion. When the moon is close to the horizon our mind tells us that it is bigger than it actually is because there are smaller, distant terrestrial references to compare it to, as opposed to the moon’s typical celestial backdrop.

Moon Distance

I put this example together to illustrate how the moon is actually FARTHER away when it’s on the horizon (therefore it’s slightly smaller) despite your brain telling you that the moon looks larger on the horizon, and the moon is CLOSER to you when it is above. The larger-moon-on-the-horizon effect is caused “moon illusion”. None of these distances or sizes are to scale, of course, but you get the point.

I created two optical illusion images to illustrate how our brains trick us. The first one is the Ponzo illusion. The idea behind this illusion is that our brains judge objects’ sizes according to their background. The moon on the horizon is set against distant landscape, making it seem larger by comparison.

Ponzo 2

These lines are exactly the same size, though the line on the bottom looks shorter due to the Ponzo illusion.

I put together the slideshow below to demonstrate how these lines are identical, but they look different in size due to the “Ponzo Illusion”.

PonzoGif1

This slideshow shows the two lines are same in length, but when the 2nd line is moved down it appears shorter. I then blocked out the sides of the photo to prove that the lines are actually equal in length contrary to our brains’ interpretation.

The second illusion I did is the Ebbinghaus. It’s generally the same idea as the Ponzo, but it uses two circles of the same size; one circle is surrounded by larger circles and the other circle of the exact same size is surrounded by smaller circles. The one surrounded by the smaller circles looks as if it is slightly larger than the circle that is identical to it but surrounded by bigger circles. Our brains see the circles, compare them to their surroundings, and make a judgment on size.

Ebbinghaus_1

The red circles are exactly the same size. It’s funny how easily our minds can fool us.

What is interesting about these sorts of optical illusions is that even after you find out that it’s an illusion and you know how it works, you still can’t stop yourself from seeing the illusion. There’s nothing wrong with admitting that our brains simply can’t help but be fooled in certain situations. We must humbly concede these faults and rely on the scientific method to explain the unexplainable rather than relying on our own faulty wiring.

Previous post

Mad Quickies 3.18

Next post

Sharper knives for sharper images, or, the 'Deli slicer' portion of your biology PhD

Gigi Chickee

Gigi Chickee

All photos are taken by me, Gigi Chickee, unless otherwise noted.

Photography Correspondent here at Mad Art Lab. Wife to my gorgeous husband, Rob. Mother to my four girls. Proud Secular Homeschooler. Photographer when the occasion arises. Seamstress in training. Skeptic always.

Follow me and my musings on Twitter: @gigichickee

2 Comments

  1. March 19, 2013 at 10:53 am

    Re: the illusion of the moon seeming bigger when it’s nearer to the horizon: If you take a picture of the moon when it is close to the horizon, it will look normal. The camera doesn’t see the illusion. Or you can bypass the illusion by bending over and looking at the moon from between your legs (if you feel like looking ridiculous).

  2. March 19, 2013 at 1:28 pm

    Thanks for the comment, dodobrd.

    If the horizon isn’t in the shot as you take a photo of the moon when it’s close to the horizon and it therefore has nothing to be compared with then, yes, the moon will look like it always does. If the horizon is in the shot though and you have objects to compare the moon against, the moon illusion will still be in effect. The camera is capable of capturing the illusion as long as you have objects in the photo to compare it with. There’s a picture from Phil Plait’s Bad Astronomy blog that includes a good example of the moon illusion with the horizon in the shot: http://blogs.discovermagazine.com/badastronomy/2010/05/13/why-does-the-moon-look-so-huge-on-the-horizon/#.UUip4FeNBmM

Leave a reply